Oops... looks like the spiders padded through here
Add products to your cart and remove them from here Lets buyPhoenix pricing
€ 17,99
Free Lite plan to start. Upgrade to unlock the full feature set when you're ready.
We aim to keep this comparison as accurate and fair as possible. If something is missing, outdated, or if Excellent Crates has shipped capabilities we missed, please contact us so we can review and update this page.
Minecraft crates comparison
Phoenix Crates vs Excellent Crates
Excellent Crates is a fully free option for servers who prioritize cost and are comfortable handling updates manually. Phoenix Crates starts free with Lite and is designed for long-term stability, broad compatibility from 1.8 to latest, and deeper integrations as your server grows.
Built to start for free, designed to scale with your vision. Whether you're setting up your first server or managing a complex network, Phoenix Crates adapts to your needs.
Start free with Lite, upgrade only when you need more
Advanced phase-based animations and physical 3D crates
Supports 1.8 through latest, plus Folia, Bedrock, and hybrid/modded servers
Team-driven release testing, docs, and active support
Buyer rating
5.0/5 stars
Based on 49 verified reviews from real buyers.
Platform support
Folia, Bedrock, modded
Supports Folia, Bedrock, and hybrid/modded servers. Excellent Crates supports none of these.
Reliability
Tested by a team
Updates are tested before they ship. Your server setup stays intact after every release.
Trusted by real servers
2.5k+ servers use Phoenix Plugins
BendersMC
470 players avg
FireMC
670 players avg
Hystic
176 players avg
MaceSMP
550 players avg
MeetionMC
553 players avg
Obsilion
265 players avg
OG Network
140 players avg
SunnySMP
243 players avg
Valatic
274 players avg
Who is this comparison for?
Excellent Crates
Best for those who prioritize a 100% free solution and are comfortable managing their own updates and troubleshooting.
Phoenix Crates
Best for those who prioritize long-term stability, modern features (Folia/Bedrock), and reliable support, whether you are a growing a small community or a large-scale network.
Community review evidence
What Excellent Crates users are reporting
Direct screenshots from public community reviews with quick quote highlights.
Community feedback from SpigotMC regarding version stability.
Community feedback from SpigotMC regarding version stability.
Community feedback from SpigotMC regarding version stability.
Community feedback from SpigotMC regarding version stability.
Community feedback from SpigotMC regarding version stability.
Community feedback from SpigotMC regarding version stability.
Note: These are user-submitted public reviews and reflect community experience, available in spigotmc.org
Quick overview
Who each plugin is for
Start here if you want the short version.
Phoenix Crates
Best for servers that prioritize uptime, compatibility, and support quality over time.
Great for any server that wants to start free now and keep scaling without switching plugin stacks later.
- Free version to start. Paid version unlocks the full feature set when needed.
- Phase-based animations, physical 3D crate models, guaranteed rewards, re-rolls, and player-choice drops.
- Supports versions 1.8 through latest, with Folia, Bedrock, hybrid and modded server support, plus deep integrations with ModelEngine, Nexo, and ItemsAdder.
- Dedicated team workflow enables pre-release testing to reduce upgrade risk.
Excellent Crates
Best for servers that prioritize a 100% free tool and are comfortable with hands-on maintenance.
Works for simple setups that can tolerate manual troubleshooting during major update cycles.
- All features completely free, no paid tier or upgrade needed.
- Community feedback often mentions extra reconfiguration after major version changes.
- No Bedrock support, no Folia support, no hybrid or modded server compatibility, and older Minecraft versions are frequently dropped over time.
Side-by-side
The key differences
Quick facts on setup, rewards, support, and server fit.
| Area | Phoenix Crates | Excellent Crates |
|---|---|---|
| Best for | Servers prioritizing long-term stability, compatibility, and team-backed support. | Servers prioritizing a fully free setup and willing to self-manage updates. |
| Who builds it | A dedicated team, full-time development. | One developer, maintained in their spare time. |
| Free version | Yes. Phoenix Crates Lite is available for any server. | Yes. All core and advanced features are free. |
| Paid/full access | One-time license unlocks full toolkit, advanced effects, and deeper integrations. | N/A. No paid tier. |
| Update reliability | Team pre-release testing prioritizes stable upgrades and setup continuity. | Community feedback often reports manual reconfiguration after major releases. |
| Crate openings | 120+ animation combinations using phases, physical 3D crate models, full GUI customization. | GUI-based animations only. No physical 3D crate support. |
| Platform support | Supports versions 1.8 through latest, plus Folia, Bedrock, and hybrid/modded servers. | No Folia support, no Bedrock support, no hybrid or modded server compatibility, and older Minecraft versions are frequently dropped. |
| Integrations | PlaceholderAPI, Vault, ModelEngine, Nexo, ItemsAdder, and more. | PlaceholderAPI and basic integrations. No ModelEngine, Nexo, or ItemsAdder support. |
| Support | Full team with docs, active changelogs, and direct responses. | Primarily community-driven support with response quality varying by issue and timing. |
If you are currently using Excellent Crates, we provide migration guidance to make switching cleaner and lower-risk.
View migration guideModern ecosystem
Built for modern server stacks
Visual snapshot of the platform coverage many growing servers require.
Folia
Threaded server support for modern high-performance deployments.
Bedrock
Native compatibility for cross-platform player experiences.
Hybrid/Modded
Designed to work with more complex plugin and mod environments.
Feature breakdown
Where Phoenix stands out
Simple examples of what changes in real use.
What you're actually comparing
This is mainly a priorities decision: fully free and self-managed, or free-to-start with stronger long-term guardrails.
Phoenix Crates
- Every feature Excellent Crates has, plus significantly more on top.
- Folia support, Bedrock compatibility, and hybrid/modded server support are all built in.
- Migration support included if you're switching from another crate plugin.
Excellent Crates
- Has the core crate features, all completely free.
- Community reports often mention extra setup work after major version updates.
- Some servers choose alternatives mainly for update consistency and support depth.
Takeaway:
If crates matter to your server at all, the reliability difference is hard to ignore.
Feature depth comparison
Phoenix Crates focuses on breadth for servers that expect to scale integrations and platform complexity over time.
Phoenix Crates
- Player-choice rewards let players pick what they get. Great for servers that want to avoid gambling-style complaints.
- Re-rolls, guaranteed drops, phase-based animations, and physical 3D crate models.
- Deep integrations with ModelEngine, Nexo, and ItemsAdder. Fully custom crate looks.
Excellent Crates
- Has the core features, all for free.
- Does not support Folia, Bedrock, or hybrid/modded servers.
- No integration with ModelEngine, Nexo, or ItemsAdder.
Takeaway:
If your roadmap includes modern platform support or advanced integration depth, Phoenix Crates gives more headroom.
The support situation
Support quality usually matters most during updates, launch events, and urgent incidents.
Phoenix Crates
- Full documentation that's actively maintained and updated.
- When something breaks, a team process helps triage and resolve issues faster.
- Real Discord, real changelogs, and you always know what changed and why.
Excellent Crates
- Support is mostly community-run, so response speed and depth can vary by issue.
- When no one has seen your issue before, troubleshooting may require extra trial-and-error.
- Some servers migrate to reduce operational risk around updates and support availability.
Takeaway:
If uptime is business-critical, team-backed maintenance usually gives more predictable outcomes.
Pricing comparison
Price vs value
Start for free with Phoenix Crates Lite. As your server evolves and needs advanced 3D effects or deeper integrations, a one-time license unlocks the full toolkit. No subscriptions, no pressure.
Phoenix Crates
- Free version available for everyone, including personal test servers and early-stage communities.
- Upgrade only when your server needs advanced effects, deeper integrations, and full tooling.
- When you do upgrade, it's a one-time license. No subscriptions.
- Dedicated pre-release testing aims to keep your setup stable across versions.
Excellent Crates
- All features completely free. No paid tier or upgrade required.
- Major updates may require additional manual reconfiguration depending on your setup.
- Support runs through the community, so troubleshooting workload can fall back to the server admin.
The key question is operational risk over time. If your server roadmap includes growth, platform changes, and higher player expectations, paying once for stronger maintenance and broader compatibility can reduce long-term downtime and migration risk.
User experience
How each one feels
The daily admin experience matters.
Setup and day-to-day use
Phoenix Crates
Well documented, logical config, and a team you can reach if something goes wrong.
Excellent Crates
The editor is outdated and community reports suggest setup is more painful than it looks. If you hit an issue, support is unreliable.
Takeaway: Phoenix Crates has better docs and real backup when something goes wrong.
Updates
Phoenix Crates
Team-tested releases are designed to preserve existing setups across updates.
Excellent Crates
Community feedback often highlights extra manual reconfiguration after major updates.
Takeaway: If you want predictable upgrade cycles, team-tested releases reduce operational friction.
Performance
Phoenix Crates
Handles many players opening crates at the same time. Packet-based animations keep things smooth.
Excellent Crates
Should be fine on quieter servers. High-traffic performance is not well documented.
Takeaway: Phoenix Crates is the safer option for any server with real player traffic.
Integrations and compatibility
Integrations and compatibility
This part matters most when you use custom models and add-ons.
Plugin integrations
Phoenix Crates
PlaceholderAPI, Vault, ModelEngine, Nexo, ItemsAdder. All supported and documented.
Excellent Crates
PlaceholderAPI and basic integrations. No support for ModelEngine, Nexo, or ItemsAdder.
Takeaway: If your server already relies on custom models or advanced item plugins, Phoenix Crates provides broader integration coverage.
Server versions and platform
Phoenix Crates
Supports versions 1.8 through latest, plus Folia, Bedrock, and hybrid/modded servers. Migration tools included if you're switching.
Excellent Crates
No Folia support. No Bedrock support. No hybrid or modded server compatibility. Older Minecraft versions are frequently dropped.
Takeaway: If long-term version coverage and modern platform support matter to your roadmap, Phoenix Crates offers broader compatibility.
Pros and cons
Real pros and cons
No fluff. Just what each one does well, and where it falls short.
Phoenix Crates
Strengths and tradeoffs
Pros
- Free Lite version to start, one-time upgrade for the full feature set
- Phase-based animations, physical 3D crates, and player-choice rewards
- Supports versions 1.8 through latest, plus Folia, Bedrock, and hybrid/modded servers
- Built by a dedicated team with active docs, testing, and support
Cons
- You will eventually pay more to unlock the full feature set
- If your server only needs very basic crates, some premium features may be more than you need
Excellent Crates
Strengths and tradeoffs
Pros
- Open source
- All features completely free, no paid tier
Cons
- Major updates may require manual reconfiguration for some setups
- Frequently drops support for older Minecraft versions
- Solo project with no dedicated team
- No Folia support, no Bedrock support, no hybrid or modded server compatibility
- No integration with ModelEngine, Nexo, or ItemsAdder
- Community support quality can vary depending on issue complexity and timing
Use case recommendations
Which one should you pick?
Fast answer based on what your server needs.
Get Phoenix Crates if...
- You want stable operations and stronger long-term compatibility coverage.
- Your server uses Bedrock, Folia, or a modded/hybrid setup.
- You want team-backed support, docs, and tested release workflows.
Go with Excellent Crates if...
- Cost is the top priority and you want all features fully free.
- You're comfortable handling extra troubleshooting after major updates.
- You don't use Bedrock, Folia, or any deep item/model integrations.
Final verdict
How Phoenix Crates compares
Excellent Crates remains a valid option for servers who want a fully free, self-managed setup. Phoenix Crates is aimed at server owners who value long-term stability, modern platform support, and team-backed maintenance while still starting free with Lite. The better choice depends on which operational tradeoffs you want over the next year, not just today.
Review your plugin roadmap, update tolerance, and support expectations before deciding.
Quick answers
FAQs
What's the real difference between Phoenix Crates and Excellent Crates?
Excellent Crates prioritizes a fully free model. Phoenix Crates prioritizes long-term stability, modern ecosystem support, and team-backed maintenance while still offering a free entry point through Lite.
Is Phoenix Crates only for big servers?
No. Phoenix Crates Lite is available for everyone, including small test servers. As your server evolves, a one-time upgrade unlocks advanced visuals and deeper integrations.
People say Excellent Crates keeps breaking on updates. Is that accurate?
Community feedback frequently mentions extra manual reconfiguration after major updates. As with many solo-maintained projects, update experience can vary by setup and version.
Where are the Phoenix Crates docs?
The official Phoenix Crates docs are maintained and always up to date. Everything from setup to advanced config to the full changelog is there.